Agility in Decision-Making: Challenges and Coping Mechanisms of School Heads

This study employed a qualitative phenomenological approach to capture the lived experiences of school heads face in decision-making. In-depth interviews (IDIs) and focus group discussions (FGDs) were conducted with 10 purposefully selected participants. Thematic analysis was used to identify key patterns and themes related to decision-making challenges, coping strategies, and leadership insights. Findings revealed six major challenges that hinder school heads’ agility in decision-making: (1) rigid bureaucratic policies and slow approval processes, (2) conflicting priorities between policy compliance and school needs, (3) limited autonomy in implementing context-specific solutions, (4) resource constraints affecting quick decision-making, (5) resistance to change from stakeholders, and (6) unclear or changing guidelines from higher authorities. To address these constraints, school heads adopted various coping mechanisms, including (1) strategic networking and liaison with higher authorities, (2) practicing adaptive leadership and creative problem-solving, (3) delegating responsibilities and empowering teachers, (4) engaging in community and partnerships, (5) consensus-building and stakeholder involvement, and (6) continuous monitoring and proactive communication. Furthermore, insights drawn from the findings suggest that (1) balancing policies and school needs, (2) maintaining strong networks, (3) promoting shared leadership, (4) leveraging community support, (5) ensuring clear communication, and (6) staying informed about policy changes are essential in enhancing school heads' decision-making agility. The results indicate that bureaucratic constraints significantly impact school heads’ ability to make timely decisions, necessitating strategic approaches to leadership agility.